democracy in action
this is not a political post... in one sense.
today, i did an interesting experiment in the concept of differentiation and democracy. i gave my students a choice in order to enable them to decide which option was in their best interest.
background information: the midterm is monday and i gave them the choice to do it in class, fifty minutes, no notes, not resources, no help. or they can take it home, use resources, notes, dictionaries, etc. with the understanding that i would expect more detail and information in that format.
the class of course approached this as if it would come to a vote and then the majority ruled. i, instead, explained that this was not going to be a democracy of majority rule, but instead where everyone was represented and they could choose what was in their own best interest... aka each student chose for herself and had "representation".
chaos ensued. the debate became animated. the issues were questioned. discussion of the pros/cons. decisions were not made. more discussion. each student now had to decide what was in her favor and what was not. chaos. stress and questions about format and expectations.
stress about what they had to do when. on the one hand, in-class meant that they had to study this weekend to prepare. they had to work now. give this weekend up. on the other, they could have the weekend and take it home, but it would require more work later, and over a longer period of time. more chaos. more animation.
one student told me that she could not live in a world with such freedom, that i needed to decide for her, that this was just too much for her to deal with. another struggled with what he wanted versus what was in his immediate best interest. he wanted to do the take-home but he didn't have time with other midterms and papers.
in the end, they will email me their choices, and i will give you the statistical breakdown of their choice. overall, i am very fascinated by their reaction to choice. that they prefer a majority rules or a dictatorship over deciding for themselves. i honestly believe that they will ultimately prefer this to the other two options.
today, i did an interesting experiment in the concept of differentiation and democracy. i gave my students a choice in order to enable them to decide which option was in their best interest.
background information: the midterm is monday and i gave them the choice to do it in class, fifty minutes, no notes, not resources, no help. or they can take it home, use resources, notes, dictionaries, etc. with the understanding that i would expect more detail and information in that format.
the class of course approached this as if it would come to a vote and then the majority ruled. i, instead, explained that this was not going to be a democracy of majority rule, but instead where everyone was represented and they could choose what was in their own best interest... aka each student chose for herself and had "representation".
chaos ensued. the debate became animated. the issues were questioned. discussion of the pros/cons. decisions were not made. more discussion. each student now had to decide what was in her favor and what was not. chaos. stress and questions about format and expectations.
stress about what they had to do when. on the one hand, in-class meant that they had to study this weekend to prepare. they had to work now. give this weekend up. on the other, they could have the weekend and take it home, but it would require more work later, and over a longer period of time. more chaos. more animation.
one student told me that she could not live in a world with such freedom, that i needed to decide for her, that this was just too much for her to deal with. another struggled with what he wanted versus what was in his immediate best interest. he wanted to do the take-home but he didn't have time with other midterms and papers.
in the end, they will email me their choices, and i will give you the statistical breakdown of their choice. overall, i am very fascinated by their reaction to choice. that they prefer a majority rules or a dictatorship over deciding for themselves. i honestly believe that they will ultimately prefer this to the other two options.
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: democracy in action.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.tiaratherapy.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/98
Leave a comment